| Product |
Pure Term Insurance |
Cash Value Insurance |
Which is better? |
|
Description |
In Term Life you pay a flat amount per month (premium) for coverage for fixed
period of time (10, 15, 20, 25 or 30 years). |
In Cash value "insurance and investment" are combined. This comes in a lot of varieties: Whole life,
Universal Life, Indexed Universal Life, Variable life , Return of Premium
(ROP) Term (yes!!! return of premium term is a cash value policy disguised as
term) |
Instead
of buying a "cash value" most experts recommend "buying term
insurance and investing the difference (BTID) approach". |
|
Detailed Analysis |
Buy Term Invest the Difference (BTID) |
Cash Value Insurance ("Trash" Value Insurance) |
Which is better? (Hint..it starts with a B!) |
|
Money Accumulation |
You accumulate your money immediately in an IRA or a
Brokerage account. You are compounding your money from the get go |
In early years you
earn very little cash value as most of it is gone
towards fees and there are hefty surrender charges. This will eat into your long-term
return as you are not compounding your money initially |
BTID |
|
Return on Money |
You can earn an average of the market (6-8% a year) if you invest long-term and with cash flowing real estate you
can generate even higher returns in the long run |
Guaranteed returns are much lower (2 -4%). Also, long term
returns will be lower due to low early accumulation. The argument is that
these should be compared to after tax returns from BTID but there are tax strategies
even with BTID like 1031 exchanges with real estate etc. |
BTID |
|
Access to Money |
You have the
flexibility to withdraw whenever you need the
money (except from an IRA). With Real estate you can access cash through
HELOC, Cash Out Refinance, or even buy a bigger property with 1031 exchange |
You either need to surrender the policy or borrow at interest rate fixed by the insurance company (5-7%) |
BTID |
|
Value of Insurance |
If you die, your family will get the face amount of insurance and the money in the IRA or brokerage or the real estate |
If you die, |
BTID |
|
Cost of Insurance |
Fact is
most people don't die during the "Term" and feel they are paying the insurance company free money (the
main reason cash value is appealing for these people) ...but what they don't
realize is they are only paying a fraction of
the face value. In the above example
for the $25 per month for $500K policy for 20 years...you pay 25X12X20 = $6K!!!!!!!!! You can easily make up this money and more from the return when
you "investment of the difference". The Insurance company will only
charge for the "odds" that you might die and a small margin for
pure term insurance |
Fact is you will pay (about 3K) every year for
this policy i.e., the cost of a 20
year term in the first 2 - 3 years!!! and
will keep paying in the same hefty amount (yeah it will earn interest on it)
to cover for the insurance costs which exponentially increase as you grow
older...when you will not really need life insurance as you will have your
retirement income and little to no financial responsibilities. Don't be fooled by the huge values
shown in illustrations by insurance agents to get you buy the cash value
insurance, they are hypothetical. Look at the
guaranteed values, in these the cash
value can actually go to zero!! even when paying 3K a year...as the low rate of return you earn
coupled with high insurance cost can take your account value to zero. You
will need to put a lot of money into this for it to work the way it is
illustrated and "generate millions" |
BTID |
Comments
Post a Comment